Boneless Dutch Herring Delivered in 2 Days!

Helen Rennie
Helen Rennie
Jan 25, 2024 • 4 min read

An hour after I shared my adventures with herring, someone knocked on my door. He looked familiar, but I am terrible with faces. Then he handed me a package of Dutch herring, and suddenly I knew exactly who he was.

It was my student Max, who is from the Netherlands and lives in a nearby town. He had heard about my herring struggles, grabbed a package from his freezer, and driven over. Really, what more could a cooking teacher ask for?

The gift was wonderful. But the truly exciting part was discovering that I could order this same herring in the United States and keep it in my freezer.

Why This Dutch Herring Is So Special

This herring is silky, delicately salted, and wonderfully easy to eat. No wrestling with a whole fish. No picking through a mouthful of troublesome bones. Just open the package and enjoy.

The fish are caught young, so the little pin bones that gave me so much trouble with other herring are too small to notice. The larger bones have already been removed before packaging. That is what makes this boneless Dutch herring such a pleasure.

Hands peeling open a package of herring on a white cutting board beside an empty plate

I love herring in a fur coat, the layered salad, but I cannot bring myself to use this fish for it. I want to taste every little bit of the herring itself, without anything getting in the way.

Think of it as Dutch sashimi. Not because the preparation is identical, but because it gives me that same pleasure of eating beautiful fish with very little interference.

Where I Ordered It and What It Cost

Max pointed me toward Vander Veen’s Dutch Store, a company in Michigan that ships throughout the United States. This was not a sponsored discovery, just a very useful tip from someone who knows his herring.

The herring I ordered came in 5-ounce and 10-ounce packages. Shipping was not cheap, but spreading that cost over several packages made it much more reasonable.

Here is what my first order cost at the time:

  • Herring: Three 10-ounce packages for $45.
  • Shipping: $15.
  • Total: $60 for 30 ounces, or almost 2 pounds of fish.
A white plate holding herring with the on-screen label Here is one 10 oz pack
One 10-ounce package gives you a useful sense of the quantity before ordering.

That worked out to about $20 per package with shipping included. For me, it was comparable to what my local fish markets charged for fish suitable for eating raw. These are the prices from my order, of course, not a promise of current pricing.

How to Handle and Eat Lightly Cured Herring

This particular herring is intended to be eaten without cooking. Please do not put this silky little beauty in a frying pan. Its texture is the whole point.

Herring can carry parasites, and this product had been frozen for parasite control. That is an important distinction: I am talking about a product prepared for this use, not suggesting that any fresh herring is ready to eat raw.

The light salt cure helps with preservation, but it does not make the fish shelf-stable or remove the need for careful refrigeration. Freezing for parasite control also does not eliminate every food-safety concern. The FDA’s seafood handling guidance is a useful reference for the distinction between parasite control and other risks from raw seafood.

My practical rule is simple: do not keep the thawed herring in the refrigerator for more than 24 hours. Eat it promptly or keep it frozen until you need it, following the package instructions.

Two-Day Shipping, Freezing, and Thawing

My order arrived with two-day shipping. The ice packs were still mostly frozen. The herring itself had thawed, but it was still very cold, so I immediately put the packages in the freezer.

I would be more cautious about ordering during warm weather. My good experience with one cold delivery is not a guarantee of how a package will travel in summer.

Once the fish was safely stored, the routine was easy:

  1. Keep the packages in the freezer until needed.
  2. Move one package to the refrigerator about 24 hours before eating.
  3. Enjoy it promptly once thawed rather than letting it linger in the refrigerator.

Normally, I try to avoid repeated freezing and thawing because fish can lose moisture and suffer in texture. But this herring has two things working in its favor: it is exceptionally fatty, and it is salted. In my experience, that combination makes the moisture loss after thawing much less noticeable.

That is a texture observation, not permission to ignore temperature control. Refreezing cannot rescue fish that has become too warm.

A Wonderful Find, and My Next Ingredient Hunt

Finding a reliable source for this herring made me wonder whether I should talk more often about ingredients I struggle to find. Apparently, sometimes the solution arrives at the front door.

My next challenge is fresh Long Island duck breast in the Boston area. I have had trouble finding any that was not previously frozen. Unlike this fatty, salted herring, duck breasts have lost a tremendous amount of moisture after freezing in my experience, so I would love a genuinely fresh source.

And if someone happens to arrive with a little duck, I am not likely to turn it away.

Max, thank you for an extraordinary Christmas gift: not just delicious herring, but a way to enjoy it again whenever the craving strikes.

Share

Helen Rennie

I teach home cooks how cooking works, with practical recipes, kitchen experiments, and detailed lessons in technique.

© 2026 Helen Rennie
Powered by Convella